The Messy Middle: Where Your Strategy Fails

And why I hate a SWOT Analysis.

There are few things I hate in this life. One of them is the dreaded SWOT analysis.

It’s become a check-the-box exercise in strategic planning. We spend two hours of an eight-hour session on it, take a picture of the flip chart, and file it away until next year. It doesn’t shape our decisions or our strategy. It just sits there.

A lot of strategies end up the same way. Real effort goes into building them, they get presented with plenty of energy, and then they never make it to the field.

I call this the messy middle. It’s everything that has to happen between announcing a strategy and seeing results, and it’s where most strategies quietly die. Here’s where I see it go wrong most often.

1. It’s poorly communicated.

I truly believe communication is one of the most valuable and most underrated skills at work. Writing a clear email matters, but listening, digesting and understanding matter more.

Strategy fails here when leadership presents the plan at a town hall and walks away. Nobody explained why it matters to the people expected to deliver it, and nobody stuck around to hear their questions.

And you have to follow up. Not once, not twice, but continually. Keep. Following. Up. If you’re making a major change or pivot in direction, this matters even more. A strategy your people don’t own is one that won’t happen.

2. You don’t think through impact and execution.

I get it. Mapping out every detail usually isn’t the executive’s job. But alongside communicating the strategy, you have to think about how it’s actually going to get done.

The people who work in the business every day will push back. That’s natural, and it’s useful, because they know far more about execution than you do. If you don’t show them how, listen to their feedback, and help them prioritize and rework their day-to-day around the new direction, the strategy will stall.

3. You don’t think about your customers.

“We’re going to sell 2x next year, because…”

Sure, it looks great on a board deck. But why will your customers buy more? What has changed in the market, in your products, or in your route to market that makes that number realistic?

Putting a target on a slide and saying “that’s it, let’s go” won’t move the needle. Your customers don’t care that you want to sell more. They need to know what’s in it for them.

It all comes down to the middle

You could have the best strategy ever written, but if you don’t build the conditions for it to succeed, it won’t matter. It’ll end up in a file next to last year’s SWOT.

I love working in the messy middle. I can think big picture when I need to, but I’m great at putting my arms around a complicated problem and finding a path through — bringing some structure and order, whether that’s through clearer communication, better planning, or keeping the customer front and centre.

Next
Next

Where Ag Companies Go Wrong When Entering a New Market